Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Freestyle Technique Drills: Big Arms v Bent Elbows

Freestyle Technique Drills Pros And Cons

I just thought I'd outline the pros and cons of learning freestyle technique drills with the bent elbow method as against the straight arm method; without progressing first from straight arms.

There are those that insist that you should teach a student to swim freestyle using the bent arm method only. That you should not teach them to do this stroke with straight arms at all.

I want to look at the pros and cons of doing this.

Straight Arms (or Big arms)

Freestyle technique drills: Straight arms
Straight Arm Method
    Pros:

  • Promotes finished strokes
    That is the arm goes all the way down to the hips on the catch pull and push phase
  • Promotes correct Head and body position

    Cons:

  • Hard for young children


Bent arms (With Kickboard)

Freestyle technique drills: Bent Arm Method
Bent Arms Method
    Pros:

  • Easy for young children
  • Easy to extend to catch up stroke

    Cons:
  • Promotes raised head and body position (seems contradictory but never-the-less that's what it does
  • Often produces drag of arms in the water reducing the effectiveness of the stroke
  • Usually produces incomplete strokes


My point is: you never get rid of a teaching tool because no matter what method you use to teach it will introduce faults that you will have to correct using other teaching tools. It has always seems to me to be better to start students with the straight arm method and progress to the bent arms.

Enjoy
   Richard

No comments:

Post a Comment

Popular Posts